the forum

31 October, 2008

To respond to the unanswered questions below, or to ask a reader's advice, simply e mail:


Q Is it true you can catch unspeakable diseases by

drinking beer straight out of the can?

A Yes. If there is any possibility that rats have been able to gain access to a storage area , there is a possibility that urine traces may be found on the containers. This can lead to Weil's disease, a rather unpleasant illness which kills a small number of people each year. This has been fairly well reported over the years and yet people still seem happy to swig straight from the can or bottle .

Margery, Bishop's Stortford

A If you are dealing in shrink-wrapped stock there is little chance of rodent contamination. But most people have no idea where the drinks they consume have been stored.

CH, Farnborough

Q Is bottle-conditioned ale a hoax? How do we know the yeast sediment was ever alive in the bottle?


You don't. The idea of bottle conditioning is that the beer gets a new lease of life with some fresh yeast, so fermentation takes place in the bottle - with all the complications that entails. The most obvious of these is the creation of carbon dioxide, which has been known to blow bottles apart - ask any home brewer . It also makes quality control

difficult. I'm not saying all bottle-conditioned beers are unreliable , but I believe you can buy perfectly good beers which do not rely on added yeast.

Adam, Sunderland

A Every beer in my shop is made with the "finest ingredients", according to

labels. Do you seriously think brewers would cut corners with dead yeast?

Clive, Stalybridge

Q I've discovered that one of my team knowingly allowed an old lady to use a 5 note instead of a 10 note because he felt sorry for her. Do I discipline him

And do I ask the customer

for the rest of the money?

SB, London

Q Can anyone recommend a way

of relieving in-store stress without resorting to drink,

locking the door, or punching someone?

Phil, Barnsley


Bookmark this

Site Search


Faith in fakes

One of the most fascinating stories in wine, fit to stand alongside the Judgement of Paris, is that of Rudy Kurniawan, a man who managed to fool friends, auction houses and experts into believing they were drinking some of the world’s most expensive wines.

Click for more »
Upcoming events


Is blended Scotch overshadowed by single malt in retailers?

  • Yes
  • No
  • Don't know